Should celebrities be forgiven for the controversial things they said years ago?

If there’s one thing the internet never forgets, it’s a celebrity’s badly phrased comment. In a world where every interview bite becomes a reaction GIF, and every offhand remark becomes a discourse starter, Bollywood stars often find themselves haunted by statements they made years ago. And honestly? Some of those moments did deserve some of the scrutiny they received.

Take Nora Fatehi. When she made her debut on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon—a genuinely historic moment for Indian pop culture—her feat was widely celebrated by fans. But soon after, the internet pulled out receipts of her problematic statement on feminism and pointed out that the global visibility she enjoyed that week was possible because of the feminist movement she had publicly dismissed.

Fatehi addressed the backlash in follow-up interviews, attempting to clarify that her words were taken out of context. She went on to say that she supports equality for women, and that her comments were criticising "radical feminism" and not Wave 1 feminism. However, for many, the damage was done, not because she voiced an unpopular opinion, but because the comment revealed a deeper lack of awareness.

But she wasn’t alone. Years earlier, Mira Rajput’s “my child is not a puppy” remark had triggered a wave of frustration among working mothers, many of whom felt their struggles were being trivialised by someone speaking from a position of immense privilege. Rajput later explained that she was speaking about her journey as a young mother, not passing judgment on anyone else. Her clarification was reasonable, but the quote lived on, recycled far beyond its original context.

Alia Bhatt, too, unintentionally wandered into choppy waters when a casual anecdote about Ranbir Kapoor telling her to “wipe off” her lipstick turned into a viral analysis of relationship dynamics. The conversation it sparked about subtle control and boundaries was important, especially considering Bhatt’s influence on young followers. But the way the internet attached the incident to Bhatt's identity, repeatedly using it as evidence of her relationship dynamic, felt disproportionate. On Koffee With Karan, Bhatt stated that the anecdote was shared playfully and was never meant to frame her relationship as controlling. She expressed surprise at the internet’s interpretation and the time people invested in peeling the layers off her supposed casual remark, but her follow-up did little to stop the clip from becoming a recurring reference point.

And who can forget Ananya Panday's “I’ve struggled too” statement, which became Bollywood’s favourite meme for months. Under the jokes, there was a real conversation to be had about privilege and access—something the internet only half-addressed before turning her into a caricature. Panday later admitted she understood why the comment upset people, a reminder that young celebrities often learn in public, under harsh lights they didn’t fully anticipate.

Even someone as widely admired as Deepika Padukone wasn’t spared. While discussing her relationship with husband Ranveer Singh on Koffee With Karan, Padukone was candid about dating other men while she was “seeing” Ranveer Singh. Naturally, it set off a storm of takes about loyalty, relationships, and double standards. The moment was pulled out of context, hitched to one meme-able poker face reaction shot from Singh, and kept alive far longer than it ever should’ve been. Padukone never clarified the remark, but the internet’s near-annual resurrection of the clip feels unnecessary at best, invasive at worst.

So, should celebs be forgiven for their problematic comments?

Of course, accountability isn’t optional for public figures. They shape culture whether they intend to or not. Their words deserve scrutiny, and their statements should be held to a standard that matches their influence. But the way that critique manifests today often blurs lines between accountability and aggression, between productive conversation and performative outrage.

Which brings us to the larger question—where should the line be drawn? At what point does calling out slide into piling on? And how should public figures, audiences, and the internet collectively navigate the distance between a misstep and a moment that defines someone for years?

There isn’t a single conclusion here—only a conversation that continues to grow as celebrity culture, social media, and public expectations collide. What remains clear is that these moments aren’t just about who said what. They’re about how we, as a digital audience, choose to respond, remember, and react.

Lead image: Getty Images

Also read: Inside the rise of brand romance, where celebrity love stories double as business deals

Also read: Red is cinema's favourite clue that something is about to change