Why do we feel compelled to give people second chances?

Here's why many of us just can't resist it.

25 January, 2025

Why do we feel compelled to give people second chances?

We often find ourselves giving people second chances, driven by the belief that they have the potential to change, grow, and seek redemption. Whether it's a friend, partner, or colleague, it's part of our nature to err and let others down. Offering a second chance can be a powerful gesture of love, understanding, and hope that they can do better. But why do we feel this compelling urge to give multiple chances? Let's explore the reasons behind this instinct.

We hope for change and redemption

It’s in our nature to remain optimistic and believe that there’s always room for improvement. This is largely due to social conditioning, as society celebrates forgiveness as a virtue (always be the bigger person). It’s this belief that convinces us that the person on the other side can learn from their mistakes and make a positive change.

In the other person’s shoes

More often than not, we imagine how it would feel if the roles were reversed. This mindset helps us show compassion, leading us to forgive and form relationships that are emotionally rich and meaningful.

We’re afraid of living with regret

The thought of ‘what if’ often drives us to offer a second chance. Letting go is never easy, especially when strong emotions and connections are involved. The possibility of losing someone who has played a significant role in our lives can make us hesitant, urging us to hold on and give them another opportunity.

What does the mind go through?

When deciding to give someone a second chance, the mind struggles to choose between logic and emotion. From a rational perspective, one considers the risks of being hurt again and replays past events that led to the current situation and breach of trust. On the emotional side, there is a pull towards the comfort of familiarity and the hope of rebuilding what was lost. This inner turmoil often leads to self-doubt, anxiety, and a shift in personal boundaries.

For the person receiving a second chance, the feeling is mixed—both relief and pressure. On one hand, they may feel grateful for the opportunity, but on the other, they may feel burdened by the responsibility to prove themselves and avoid repeating past mistakes.

Offering someone a second chance is a blend of hope, kindness, and self-reflection. It demonstrates our ability to forgive and our need for connection, but it also reveals our fears and emotions. The decision to extend a second chance requires careful thought, balancing empathy with self-respect. By recognising the motivations behind this impulse, we can make choices that honour both our values and personal boundaries.

Lead image: Netflix

Also read: How to reconnect with your partner after a series of bad fights

Also read: How to have a hard conversation with your partner without turning it into a huge fight

Also read: Is makeup sex the best way to resolve a fight?

Comment