The Do’s and Don’ts of holiday gifting rules: who gets a present, a voucher, or absolutely nothing

Between leaving elaborate comments for the ethereal being that is your best friend and adding former friends to the anointed list of ‘Muted: always’, we’ve been conducting unconscious background checks on our social circles for years. But when the sleigh bells come a-ringing, so does the holiday gift filtering. Holiday shopping is no longer just about spreading joy. It’s about reviewing everyone’s performance over the preceding financial year and deciding who gets a thoughtful present, who gets a voucher, and who gets the gift of being left on read.

There are two kinds of people during the holiday season: those who believe gifting is a love language, one that often determines the health of a relationship, and those who treat it like a legally binding contract, the absence of which could result in a lifetime of social winter. Unfortunately, these two types often end up shopping for each other.

The festive season is supposed to be about generosity. But in this economy, generosity needs a budget, a spreadsheet, and occasionally, legal counsel. Which is why this year, we’re approaching our holiday gift lists the way we approach our Instagram following: ruthlessly curating, periodically auditing, and removing anyone who no longer serves the plot.

Do: Gift the people who cherish you and remember the little things

Don't: Confuse proximity with intimacy

This is crucial. Convenience isn't connection. Just because someone sits beside you at work doesn't mean they deserve a personalised hamper with artisanal chocolate, luxury skincare, and a handwritten note detailing the significance of your relationship. Sometimes, a relationship is simply two people who have survived the same quarterly review, devastating midterm, or particularly difficult boss. That's beautiful. That's community. That is also a perfectly reasonable occasion for a box of biscuits.

Do: Keep vouchers for folks you like but don’t know

Enter the acquaintance squad: a unique category of individuals who occupy your life, but not necessarily your thoughts. Your manager, your new neighbour, that one NRI cousin whose personality you cannot recall without checking the family WhatsApp group. You don't dislike them. You simply couldn't identify their signature fragrance if your life depended on it.

Enter the gift voucher: the Switzerland of holiday gifting. It's diplomatic, useful, and carries no risk of buying someone a moisturiser for skin concerns they don't have. A voucher says, ‘I value our relationship,’ without implying that you've spent three weeks studying their Pinterest boards. Just don't hand someone a generic voucher with the enthusiasm of a disgruntled HR department. A little wrapping and a few kind words go a long way.

Don't: Reward inconsistent behaviour with cashmere

We're talking about the people who bombard your phone with calls and texts only when their latest situationship inevitably falls apart. The relative who scrutinised your perfectly appropriate outfit with the dedication of an assassin of personal boundaries. The ex who resurfaces every December like a seasonal infection. And the person who has repeatedly demonstrated that, to them, an apology is simply the opening act for doing the exact same thing again.

These individuals do not need expensive gifts. They need consequences.

Of course, you can take the high road. Send a polite card, wish them well, or purchase a modest gift if social circumstances demand it. But don't spend your hard-earned money on someone who treats your emotional bandwidth like a tennis ball. And if someone has spent the entire year disrespecting you, a beautifully wrapped book on emotional intelligence (perhaps with a few chapters on recognising the need for lifelong therapy) might seem tempting. Resist the urge, unless you're prepared for the family group chat to turn into a war crimes tribunal.

The holidays are a time to cherish those who stood by you, politely acknowledge those who tried, and move on from the ones who couldn't remember you existed until they needed something. Think of your holiday gift list as the annual report of your relationships. Let it be thoughtful. Let it be generous. Let it be a little petty, if the situation warrants it. But above all, let it be yours. Perhaps the best gift you can give yourself this year is accepting that a holiday present isn't meant for everyone. Just the people you actually want to give one to.

Lead image: 

Also read: Did life really feel better before 2020, or are we just nostalgic?

Also read: Are we overthinking social media posts more than ever?