A case for the finest Bridgerton brother and why Benedict’s charm does not erase his red flags

The new season of Bridgerton has finally put the spotlight on everyone’s favourite artistic Bridgerton brother, and naturally, the internet has opinions. While fans have long swooned over Benedict’s softness, humour, and slightly chaotic charm, his Season 4 storyline has also sparked a very important debate: is he the ultimate green flag romantic hero, or are there a few red flags hiding beneath all that charm? 

As loyal members of the ton (and extremely invested viewers), we decided it was only fair to lay down a debate. On one side of this article is a devoted Benedict defender, Shreya Shah, ready to list every green flag that makes him one of the most refreshing romantic heroes in the ton. On the other hand, Schenelle Dsouza believes those dreamy moments might also be hiding a few red flags worth discussing, especially in Season 4. So let's get into it. 

Consider this a very civilised Bridgerton-style debate, with gloves on, of course.

The green flags that make Benedict dangerously charming

Dearest gentle reader, I have a confession to make. Whilst the world sighed over Anthony’s brooding and laughed over Colin’s antics, my heart had always been drawn to the sensitive, mischievous, and supportive Benedict. Tantalising glimpses of his talents, from the arts to the banter, danced off the pages of Julia Quinn’s novels and translated perfectly onto Netflix’s swoon-worthy adaptation. 

It's not just his charming smile that tenderly, tentatively knocked at my heart and found a permanent place within. It’s not just his heightened chivalry or emotional sensitivity. These were all just cherries on the cake. The entire romantic trope is built on a refreshing premise: he is kind. In the world, and very much in the Bridgerton microcosm, romantic heroes oscillate between brooding bad boy and emotionally unavailable hottie. But not Benedict. He stands out for his soft, genuine decency. Whether you met him through the romance novel or fell for him on TV, Benedict is that rare man who leads with softness and wins entirely. 

Regency society is famously rigid, but Benedict is surprisingly flexible in his worldview. In the show, Benedict moves comfortably in artistic circles that are far more forward than the traditional ton. His friendships include women who live unconventional lives, and he never judges them for it. Instead, he listens, learns, and supports their choices. In the books, this respect becomes even clearer. His connection with Sophie isn’t built on status or convenience. It’s built on a genuine fascination with who she is. A lot of fictional romantic heroes rely on emotional stoicism to appear strong. Benedict does the opposite.

He openly grapples with insecurity about his place in the world. As the second Bridgerton son, he isn’t burdened with the same responsibilities as Anthony, but he also doesn’t have a clearly defined role. That uncertainty leads him to explore art, creativity, and self-discovery. And crucially, he doesn’t hide that struggle. Instead of pretending he has everything figured out, Benedict admits when he’s lost. That level of vulnerability is incredibly attractive because it signals emotional maturity.

I feel like true romance is in the little things. Grand gestures are lovely, and there’s a time and moment for them too, but paying thought and consideration to the little, everyday things is precious. Benedict listens, truly listens, and files away every little like and dislike. He cherishes the happiness of simple things. Remember the kite-flying episode? This kind of “I see you” romance is intoxicating. 

I do get that he isn’t a perfect hero, but who is? He makes mistakes and sometimes gets lost in his own privilege. But he learns. And that willingness to evolve is what ultimately makes him such a green flag. Yes, he needs a little prodding. He aches to be free of societal considerations, and is yet painfully aware (and respectful) of the consequences. His biggest green flag, according to me, is actually that. He cares from within, not perfunctorily. From his mother to his sisters to his lady-love, he treats women as intelligent beings. You can tell he doesn’t impose his will for the sake of it, but because he genuinely feels that there is no other way towards a smoother road. In a culture obsessed with perfection, it’s nice to root for a character who’s still becoming the best version of himself.

While his older brother Anthony is intense and duty-bound, and Colin leans toward charming chaos, and we have no idea what little Gregory will grow up to be, Benedict is his own person entirely: an artist, a dreamer, and the type of irresistible man who actually listens.

The not-so-perfect side of Benedict Bridgerton

Benedict's storyline in Season 4 may have raised a few questionable red flags we must discuss (and no, this isn't just about the staircase proposal).

I have to maintain that Benedict has always been my favourite Bridgerton brother right from the get-go, even when his screen time was limited to showcasing his artistic capabilities and his rather enthusiastic social life. That said, he has never been without his flaws, which one cannot argue are quite evidently red flag material. Of course, none of the Bridgerton siblings was ever written to be perfect, so we're not going to dive right back to the beginning (even though we probably could). Instead, let’s start with the Season 4 opening ball hosted by Lady Bridgerton.

To begin with, the first and most glaring misstep is the moment when he takes Sophie unescorted into the garden to dance. Within the context of Regency society, this is far more grave than it may seem to a modern audience. Social rules around courtship were rigid, and women were almost always expected to be accompanied by a chaperone when spending time with a gentleman. Their being seen alone together could easily spark gossip or speculation about her character, which Benedict did not seem to care about. He treats the moment as merely harmless flirtation, but in reality, it reflects his tendency to disregard the social consequences Sophie might face.

Another recurring issue is Benedict’s somewhat idealistic “I don’t see class” outlook. On the surface, this sounds progressive and romantic, especially in a society obsessed with hierarchy. However, it also uncovers a certain privileged naivety. Sophie’s life is shaped by the realities of class and reputation in ways Benedict simply does not fully comprehend. We see this repeatedly, from the moment he insists on bringing her to London and arranging a position for her in his own household without fully considering how precarious that situation might be for her, to the way he continues to pursue her despite the obvious risks attached to their relationship. By insisting that class does not matter, he unintentionally dismisses the very real obstacles Sophie has had to navigate. More tellingly, he seems to overlook the fact that such a relationship would not only affect Sophie but also his own family.

Another consistent flaw is his behaviour towards Sophie, which becomes increasingly persistent as the story progresses. He repeatedly makes advances, attempts to kiss her, and pushes romantic boundaries, which at one point even prompts Sophie to question his actions and why he thinks it was appropriate to behave this way with her when he would never treat another lady of society in the same manner. The moment subtly exposes a double standard, one where Sophie is placed in a position that feels less protected and more uncertain.

And then, of course, there is the moment that fans will probably debate the most: when Benedict asks Sophie to be his mistress. Within the show's world, this suggestion carries complicated implications. Becoming a mistress would mean existing outside the respectability of marriage, something that could permanently define a woman’s social standing. For Sophie, the suggestion is even more loaded given her family history, making the proposal feel particularly insensitive. What Benedict sees as a practical solution reveals a blind spot in his understanding of the emotional weight such a role would carry for her.

Taken together, these moments do not necessarily make Benedict a villain. If anything, they highlight the contradictions that make his character interesting, charming, and well-meaning, yet impulsive, privileged, and occasionally oblivious to the consequences of his actions. And perhaps that is what makes him such a compelling Bridgerton brother in the first place.

Lead image: Netflix 

Also read: Breaking the confidence myth—why you actually don’t need to have it all figured out  

Also read: Stroll, don’t scroll: 5 fun things to do during lunch that don’t involve your phone